Though Christian ministers have often offered invocations before governmental meetings, the federal courts have consistently ruled that the prayers must be non-sectarian. In Dumfries, this led town leaders in 2010 to pass a resolution specifically advising anyone offering the invocation that “Prayers may not be addressed to ‘Jesus,’ ‘Christ,’ or any variation on those names. A prayer is ‘addressed’ to Jesus if it contains the phrase, ‘in Jesus’ name we pray’ or anything similar.”
Now some in Dumfries are having second thoughts, according to Uriah Kiser of PotomacLocal.com. Councilman Jerry Foreman has submitted a new resolution deleting the specific mentions of Jesus and Christ cited above. “By amending this language the resolution stays non-denominational. It doesn’t specifically call one religious leader or one religion out,” Foreman said in Kiser’s piece.
Prince William County also adopted a similar policy, InsideNova.com reported last year, instructing speakers that “invocations should not include references to religious figures such as Jesus Christ, to images such as a crucifix, or to teaching from such sources as the Koran or the Book of Mormon.”
If Prince William County has a policy to not include references to specific religious deities, someone forgot to tell the BOCS about it. I distinctly heard a specific deity this afternoon. On the other hand, I hear that many of the ministers don’t want to be included in a mini invocation that forbids them to focus their worship on the very deity that they revere. I don’t blame them. Obviously Christians pray to Jesus, Jews to God, Muslims to Allah, etc.
So, we have a problem. What is the best solution? It seems to me that rather than invite visiting ministers to come pray but not dare mention their deity, why not have a moment of silence. There is a remarkable idea. Everyone can pray to whomever they want. If they don’t pray, then those at public meetings can make up a grocery list in their heads. No one will be the wiser.
Moments of silence can be very personal and personally rewarding. Perhaps the supervisor sitting 2 seats away gets on your last nerve. Speak to your higher power about giving you patience. It just might work. Moments of silence take the focus off the individual. There is less of a temptation to gawk around the room. Not everyone prays by bowing their head. Not everyone closes their eyes. For those more contentious meetings, have a 2 minutes of silence. Longer prayer, longer grocery list –no one has to know.
Everyone will feel comfortable. Visiting pastors won’t have to compromise themselves, “others” who aren’t part of mainstream religion won’t have to feel that awkward moment that every “other” feels at the start of the BOCS meeting. I think that the PW County is big enough to handle this one. It needs to be adopted at all levels of government and, unlike the school board, it needs to practice its own policy. Adopting a moment of silence just takes the heat off of everyone. Oh, and Dumfries can follow suit too.